Funds HotlineJanuary 20, 2023 AIF participation in Credit Default SwapsIntroductionAs of 30 June 2022, Alternative Investment Funds (“AIFs”) registered with the Securities and Exchange Board of India (“SEBI”) were reported to have collectively allocated 30% of their total investments towards debt and securitized debt instruments.1 In response, SEBI2 has amended3 the AIF Regulations (“Amendment”) to authorise AIFs to buy and sell credit default swaps (“CDS”)4 to hedge or assume credit risks. This authorisation, however, is subject to certain restrictions and conditions, which vary for various categories of AIFs, which have been explained further in a circular (“Circular”).5 These are outlined below.
The Circular stipulates that all CDS transactions must be performed on a platform which is regulated by SEBI or the Reserve Bank of India (“RBI”). These transactions ought to also be compliant with the Master Direction – Reserve Bank of India (Credit Derivatives) Directions, 2022 (“Master Direction”). The key features of the Master Direction which are relevant to AIFs transacting in CDS are outlined below
Observation and remarksBy permitting AIFs to participate in CDS, SEBI has facilitated AIFs to manage and transfer their credit risks, and also introduce new institutional players in the market. SEBI remains circumspect about allowing Category II AIFs to become protection sellers without earmarking certain unencumbered securities of an equivalent value to the CDS. Despite this circumspection, the Amendments are welcome inasmuch as they allow AIFs to guarantee the creditworthiness of certain debt instruments. This allows greater flexibility as opposed to SEBI’s traditional stance against allowing AIFs to undertake any guarantees. Be that as it may, it remains to be seen whether the AIF industry’s demand for CDS transactions is sustainable in the current regulatory framework. One might remember that mutual funds were permitted to participate in the CDS market a decade ago. However, the market did not take off. The premium for buying CDS ought to be commensurate with the advantage derived by AIFs by hedging credit risks. In the absence of market makers enabling commercial viability of CDS transactions, the new regulatory environment is unlikely to make the market be sustainable. It remains to be seen whether the AIFs’ interest in CDS transactions is sustainable in the long term, or if it will follow the footsteps of mutual funds.
(The authors would like to acknowledge and thank Athul Kumar (student, Symbiosis Law School, Pune) for his contribution to this hotline.) You can direct your queries or comments to the authors 1 SEBI Board Meeting Memorandum dated December 20, 2022. 2 SEBI (Alternative Investment Funds) (Amendment) Regulations, 2023. 3 Regulations 16(1)(aa), 17(da), 18(ab) and 20(11). 4 A CDS is defined as “a credit derivative contract in which one counterparty (protection seller) commits to pay to the other counterparty (protection buyer) in the case of a credit event with respect to a reference entity and in return, the protection buyer makes periodic payments (premium) to the protection seller until the maturity of the contract or the credit event, whichever is earlier.” See: Para 2(f), Master Direction – Reserve Bank of India (Credit Derivatives) Directions, 2022 (February 10, 2022, FMRD.DIRD.10/14.03.004/2021-22). 5 SEBI/HO/AFD/PoD/CIR/2023/15. 6 SEBI circular no. CIR/IMD/DF/10/2013 dated July 29, 2013. 7 Regulation 20 (11), AIF Regulations. 8 Regulation 20 (11), AIF Regulations. 9 Para 7, RBI Master Directions. 10 Para 7, RBI Master Directions. 11 Para 8, RBI Master Directions. 12 Para 12, RBI Master Directions. DisclaimerThe contents of this hotline should not be construed as legal opinion. View detailed disclaimer. |
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Introduction
As of 30 June 2022, Alternative Investment Funds (“AIFs”) registered with the Securities and Exchange Board of India (“SEBI”) were reported to have collectively allocated 30% of their total investments towards debt and securitized debt instruments.1 In response, SEBI2 has amended3 the AIF Regulations (“Amendment”) to authorise AIFs to buy and sell credit default swaps (“CDS”)4 to hedge or assume credit risks. This authorisation, however, is subject to certain restrictions and conditions, which vary for various categories of AIFs, which have been explained further in a circular (“Circular”).5 These are outlined below.
|
Particulars |
Category I |
Category II |
Category III |
|
|
AIF as a buyer of CDS |
Category I and Category II AIFs may buy CDS, but only to hedge risks on underlying debt investments. |
Category III AIFs may buy CDS for hedging risks on an underlying debt investment. A Category III AIF may also buy CDS for purposes other than hedging of risks. However, such exposure to CDS may not exceed twice the net asset value of the fund.6 |
||
|
AIF as a seller of CDS |
The Amendment and Circular are silent in this regard. We view this as being not permitted. |
Category II AIFs may to sell CDS by earmarking unencumbered Government bonds/treasury bills equivalent to the CDS exposure so that it does not amount to leverage. |
Category III AIFs may sell CDS provided that “effective leverage is undertaken” within permissible limits (i.e., twice the net asset value of the fund). They may sell CDS by earmarking unencumbered Government bonds/treasury bills equivalent to the CDS exposure. Such CDS exposure may not amount to leverage. |
|
|
Concentration Norms |
Not applicable as the Amendment and the Circular are silent on the sale of CDS by Category I AIFs. |
Total exposure to investee companies via CDS should not breach the concentration norms. These norms, for Category II AIFs, provide that no more than 25% of an AIF’s investible funds may be invested in one investee company. |
Any unhedged position resulting in the gross value of unhedged positions across all CDS transactions exceeding 25% of investable funds may be undertaken only after intimating all investors. |
|
|
Custodian |
Sponsor / Manager of a Category I or Category II AIF undertaking CDS transactions must appoint a custodian who is registered with SEBI irrespective of the corpus size.7 |
All Category III AIFs are required to appoint a custodian under the AIF Regulations.8 |
||
|
Reporting |
Details of CDS transactions must be reported to the appointed custodian before the end of the following working day (in the manner prescribed by the custodian). |
|||
|
Breach due to earmarked securities falling below the CDS exposure |
Not applicable as the Amendment and the Circular are silent on the sale of CDS by Category I AIFs. |
If the earmarked securities of a Category II or III AIF fall below its CDS exposure, it must
If the AIF fails to rectify the breach, then the custodian is required to report the details thereof to SEBI on the following working day. |
||
|
Breach in leverage limits |
Not Applicable as Category II AIFs are not permitted to sell CDS in a manner that is tantamount to leverage. |
A Category III AIF in breach of the leverage limits must
|
||
|
Cooling-off period |
Category I and Category AIFs transacting in CDS must maintain a cooling-off period of thirty days between two periods of any borrowing or leverage that they undertake. |
Not applicable. |
||
The Circular stipulates that all CDS transactions must be performed on a platform which is regulated by SEBI or the Reserve Bank of India (“RBI”). These transactions ought to also be compliant with the Master Direction – Reserve Bank of India (Credit Derivatives) Directions, 2022 (“Master Direction”). The key features of the Master Direction which are relevant to AIFs transacting in CDS are outlined below
-
Reference Entities: AIFs may enter into a CDS contract only to hedge against or assume risks of investees (called “reference entities”) which are residents of India, against whose credit risk the CDS contract is entered into.9
-
Reference Obligations:The Master Direction refer to the underlying assets to which a CDS contract is linked as “reference obligations”. AIFs are prohibited from entering into CDS contracts which are linked to asset-backed securities/mortgage-backed securities or structured obligations.10
-
Related Parties: CDS transactions are not permitted when the reference entity is a related party to either the “protection buyer” or the “protection seller”.11
-
Accounting: To follow SEBI prescribed accounting standards. In the absence such standards, AIFs ought to follow the guidance issued by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India.12
Observation and remarks
By permitting AIFs to participate in CDS, SEBI has facilitated AIFs to manage and transfer their credit risks, and also introduce new institutional players in the market. SEBI remains circumspect about allowing Category II AIFs to become protection sellers without earmarking certain unencumbered securities of an equivalent value to the CDS. Despite this circumspection, the Amendments are welcome inasmuch as they allow AIFs to guarantee the creditworthiness of certain debt instruments. This allows greater flexibility as opposed to SEBI’s traditional stance against allowing AIFs to undertake any guarantees.
Be that as it may, it remains to be seen whether the AIF industry’s demand for CDS transactions is sustainable in the current regulatory framework. One might remember that mutual funds were permitted to participate in the CDS market a decade ago. However, the market did not take off. The premium for buying CDS ought to be commensurate with the advantage derived by AIFs by hedging credit risks. In the absence of market makers enabling commercial viability of CDS transactions, the new regulatory environment is unlikely to make the market be sustainable. It remains to be seen whether the AIFs’ interest in CDS transactions is sustainable in the long term, or if it will follow the footsteps of mutual funds.
– Nandini Pathak & Dhruv Sanghavi
(The authors would like to acknowledge and thank Athul Kumar (student, Symbiosis Law School, Pune) for his contribution to this hotline.)
You can direct your queries or comments to the authors
1 SEBI Board Meeting Memorandum dated December 20, 2022.
2 SEBI (Alternative Investment Funds) (Amendment) Regulations, 2023.
3 Regulations 16(1)(aa), 17(da), 18(ab) and 20(11).
4 A CDS is defined as “a credit derivative contract in which one counterparty (protection seller) commits to pay to the other counterparty (protection buyer) in the case of a credit event with respect to a reference entity and in return, the protection buyer makes periodic payments (premium) to the protection seller until the maturity of the contract or the credit event, whichever is earlier.” See: Para 2(f), Master Direction – Reserve Bank of India (Credit Derivatives) Directions, 2022 (February 10, 2022, FMRD.DIRD.10/14.03.004/2021-22).
5 SEBI/HO/AFD/PoD/CIR/2023/15.
6 SEBI circular no. CIR/IMD/DF/10/2013 dated July 29, 2013.
7 Regulation 20 (11), AIF Regulations.
8 Regulation 20 (11), AIF Regulations.
9 Para 7, RBI Master Directions.
10 Para 7, RBI Master Directions.
11 Para 8, RBI Master Directions.
12 Para 12, RBI Master Directions.
Disclaimer
The contents of this hotline should not be construed as legal opinion. View detailed disclaimer.
Research PapersFAQs on Setting Up of Offices in India FAQs on Downstream Investment Gaming Law 2024 |
Research ArticlesThe Revolution Realized: Bitcoin's Triumph The Bitcoin Effect Acquirers Beware: Indian Merger Control Regime Revamped! |
AudioSecurities Market Regulator’s Continued Quest Against “Unfiltered” Financial Advice Digital Lending - Part 1 - What's New with NBFC P2Ps Renewable Roadmap: Budget 2024 and Beyond - Part I |
NDA ConnectConnect with us at events, |
NDA Hotline |