NISHITH.TV
  • Mumbai
  • Silicon Valley
  • Bengaluru
  • Singapore
  • Mumbai BKC
  • New Delhi
  • Munich
  • New York

Locations

  • Mumbai
  • Silicon Valley
  • Bengaluru
  • Singapore
  • Mumbai BKC
  • New Delhi
  • Munich
  • New York
  • Content
  • Home
  • ABOUT US
  • NDA in the Media
  • Areas of Service
  • Research and Articles
  • Opportunities
  • Contact
  • NDACloud
  • Client Access
  • Member Access
  • Events and Calender
  • How we perform
  • Knowledge anywhere, anytime
  • See our recent deals
  • Up to date legal developments
  • Case studies in M&A

Research and Articles

HTMLPDF

  • Research at NDA
  • Research Papers
  • Research Articles
  • NDA Think Tanks
  • NDA Hotline
  • New Ali Gunjan
  • Japan Desk ジャパンデスク

NDA-Hotline


  • Capital Markets Hotline
  • Companies Act Series
  • Climate Change Related Legal Issues
  • Competition Law Hotline
  • Corpsec Hotline
  • Court Corner
  • Cross Examination
  • Deal Destination
  • Debt Funding in India Series
  • Dispute Resolution Hotline
  • Education Sector Hotline
  • FEMA Hotline
  • Financial Service Update
  • Food & Beverages Hotline
  • Funds Hotline
  • Gaming Law Wrap
  • GIFT City Express
  • Green Hotline
  • HR Law Hotline
  • iCe Hotline
  • Insolvency and Bankruptcy Hotline
  • International Trade Hotlines
  • Investment Funds: Monthly Digest
  • IP Hotline
  • IP Lab
  • Legal Update
  • Lit Corner
  • M&A Disputes Series
  • M&A Hotline
  • M&A Interactive
  • Media Hotline
  • New Publication
  • Other Hotline
  • Pharma & Healthcare Update
  • Private Client Wrap
  • Private Debt Hotline
  • Private Equity Corner
  • Real Estate Update
  • Realty Check
  • Regulatory Digest
  • Regulatory Hotline
  • Renewable Corner
  • SEZ Hotline
  • Social Sector Hotline
  • Tax Hotline
  • Technology & Tax Series
  • Technology Law Analysis
  • Telecom Hotline
  • The Startups Series
  • White Collar and Investigations Practice
  • Yes, Governance Matters.
  • Japan Desk ジャパンデスク

Tax Hotline

October 11, 2004

Gains on sale of shares treated as 'Business Income' in the hands of FIIs

In a recent tax ruling pronounced by the Authority for Advance Rulings ("AAR") it was held that, gains arising to Foreign Institutional Investors ("FIIs") on sale of their portfolio investments in India were in the nature of business income, and would not be taxable in India in the absence of a permanent establishment ("PE") in India.

The applicant in this case was an investment fund organised in the US and invested in India under the FII route. The ruling was sought from the AAR for the specific determination as to whether gains arising in India from the trading of shares would be regarded as business income or capital gains.

Currently, while long term capital gains on listed securities are tax exempt in India under the domestic law, a 10% tax is levied on short term capital gains on listed securities. In the case of unlisted securities, long term capital gains are subject to tax at the rate of 10%, while short term capital gains are taxed at the rate of 30%.

While pronouncing that the gains were in the nature of business income, the AAR laid down the following principles:

  • Mere power in the byelaws to trade in shares is not decisive of the nature of transaction. It must be established that a company dealing in shares is holding the same as stock in trade;

  • Substantial nature of transactions, manner of maintaining records and magnitude of transactions are relevant factors in determination of the nature of transactions; and

  • Trading in shares with the motive of earning profit would result in the transaction being regarded as adventure in the nature of trade.

The AAR also examined as to whether the applicant had a PE in India due to the presence of a custodian in India. The AAR after perusing the custodian agreement and various other documents held that the custodian was an agent of independent status and hence would not be treated as a PE in India. Thus, relying on the provisions of Article 7 of the India-US tax treaty, they held that in the absence of a PE in India, the trading income of the applicant will be taxable only in the US and cannot be taxable in India.

It should be noted that advance rulings are binding only on the applicant and in respect of the specific transaction in relation to which such advance ruling was sought.

Mission and Vision


Distinctly Different

What's New


SEBI approves five proposals on AIF reforms
Investment Funds: Monthly Digest: March 30,2023
SEBI Modifies FPI Master Circular: Onboarding Process Streamlined
Regulatory Hotline : March 29,2023

Events


Webinars

Sovereign Wealth Fund and Pension Funds investments in India: Unique Considerations and Critical Issues
March 09,2023 - March 09,2023

This event is over. For event material please click here


Seminar

Fund Structuring and Investments in 2023 - Luncheon and Knowledge Sessions
March 24,2023 - March 24,2023

This event is over. For event material please click here


Round Table

Investing In Net Zero
July 22,2022 - July 22,2022

This event is over. For event material please click here

News Roundup


News Articles

Shareholder Activism: An ESG tool or a Founder’s curse?
October 13,2022

Quotes

Sebi relaxes FPI onboarding norms but gaps remain in framework, say experts
March 28,2023

Newsletters


Investment Funds: Monthly Digest

SEBI approves five proposals on AIF reforms
March 30,2023

Regulatory Hotline

SEBI Modifies FPI Master Circular: Onboarding Process Streamlined
March 29,2023

Tax Hotline

Amendments to Finance Bill, 2023
March 29,2023

  • Disclaimer
  • Content
  • Feedback
  • Walkthrough
  • Subscribe
Nishith Desai Associates@2016 All rights reserved.