NISHITH.TV
  • Mumbai
  • Silicon Valley
  • Bengaluru
  • Singapore
  • Mumbai BKC
  • New Delhi
  • Munich
  • New York

Locations

  • Mumbai
  • Silicon Valley
  • Bengaluru
  • Singapore
  • Mumbai BKC
  • New Delhi
  • Munich
  • New York
  • Content
  • Home
  • ABOUT US
  • NDA in the Media
  • Areas of Service
  • Research and Articles
  • Opportunities
  • Contact
  • NDACloud
  • Client Access
  • Member Access
  • Events and Calender
  • How we perform
  • Knowledge anywhere, anytime
  • See our recent deals
  • Up to date legal developments
  • Case studies in M&A

Research and Articles

HTMLPDF

  • Research at NDA
  • Research Papers
  • Research Articles
  • NDA Think Tanks
  • NDA Hotline
  • New Ali Gunjan
  • Japan Desk ジャパンデスク

NDA-Hotline


  • Debt Funding in India Series
  • Private Equity Corner
  • The Startups Series
  • Court Corner
  • Investment Funds: Monthly Digest
  • Insolvency and Bankruptcy Hotline
  • Deal Destination
  • New Publication
  • M&A Interactive
  • Lit Corner
  • Private Debt Hotline
  • Food & Beverages Hotline
  • Companies Act Series
  • Gaming Law Wrap
  • Private Client Wrap
  • GIFT City Express
  • Regulatory Hotline
  • Capital Markets Hotline
  • Tax Hotline
  • Corpsec Hotline
  • Dispute Resolution Hotline
  • M&A Hotline
  • Pharma & Healthcare Update
  • Competition Law Hotline
  • HR Law Hotline
  • IP Hotline
  • Telecom Hotline
  • FEMA Hotline
  • Social Sector Hotline
  • iCe Hotline
  • SEZ Hotline
  • Media Hotline
  • Funds Hotline
  • Education Sector Hotline
  • International Trade Hotlines
  • Other Hotline
  • Real Estate Update
  • Realty Check
  • White Collar and Investigations Practice
  • Legal Update
  • IP Lab
  • Cross Examination
  • Technology & Tax Series
  • Technology Law Analysis
  • Yes, Governance Matters.
  • Financial Service Update
  • Japan Desk ジャパンデスク

Tax Hotline

January 13, 2005

AAR denies ruling on a transfer pricing application

Recently, the Indian Advance Ruling Authority ("AAR") had an opportunity to adjudicate upon transfer pricing questions raised for the first time in an advance ruling application by Instrumentarium Corporation ("the Applicant"), a Finnish resident. The AAR stated that adjudication on the issue raised by the Applicant was outside its scope and that the Applicant would be required to adhere to the Indian transfer pricing regulations.

The Applicant had given interest-free loan to its wholly owned subsidiary ("Datex") in India and raised, inter alia, the question before the AAR that applying arm's length price to this transaction would be detrimental to the Indian revenue base and hence this transaction should be outside the purview of the Indian transfer pricing regulations .

The Applicant contended that the fact that the loan was an interest free loan would work out to the benefit of the Indian Tax Authorities since under the India-Finland Double Taxation Treaty ("Treaty") any interest income of the Applicant would be taxed at a concessional rate, while under the Income Tax Act, 1961("ITA") the income of Datex would be taxed at the rate of 35%. This argument sprung from the fact that the interest free loan would enhance the profits of Datex and would thus increase the taxes collected in India on the transaction. The Applicant relied on Section 92(3) of the ITA which states that the transfer pricing provisions would not apply if the transaction carried out between two parties would lead to the erosion of the taxable revenue in India, if carried out at an arm's length. The Applicant also relied on the non-discrimination provisions under the Treaty and stated that as transfer pricing provisions did not apply to transactions between two Indian residents, applying them to the Applicant would be discriminatory.

The AAR held that the question raised did not relate to tax liability of the Applicant arising out of this transaction but related to consequences of implementation of transfer pricing provisions on the Indian exchequer. Therefore, the AAR was not bound to rule on the same. The AAR further held that even if the impact of applying arm's length price between two parties was detrimental to the tax revenue, it was for the income tax authorities to determine the same and thus allow the parties to the transaction not to carry out the same at an arm's length price and not the AAR.

The AAR also dismissed the non-discrimination contention raised by the Applicant and stated that non-discrimination provisions can only be invoked by the nationals (i.e. individuals) of the contracting states and not by a company. The AAR held that in any case, it was not open to either the Applicant or the AAR to determine the issue of the applicability of the transfer pricing provisions under ITA and the same would have to be determined by the income tax authorities at the time of assessment of Datex. The AAR took the view that determination of arm's length price involves determination of fair market rate of interest and that the same is outside its purview.Accordingly, the AAR stated that it cannot give a ruling on this issue. However, it ruled that the Applicant would be required to adhere to the transfer pricing regulations under the ITA.

It must also be borne in mind that an advance ruling is binding only on the parties to the ruling. As regards third parties, such a ruling would have only a persuasive value. This decision does not throw sufficient light on the ability of foreign companies to seek advance ruling on the applicability of transfer pricing provisions in India.

 
 

Source: Judgement of AAR in the matter of INSTRUMENTARIUM CORPORATION (A.A.R. No. 609 of 2003)

Mission and Vision


Distinctly Different

What's New


Mid-year Regulatory Update 2022: Medical Device Industry in India
Pharma & Healthcare Update: June 28,2022
Mid-year Update: Digital Health in India
Pharma & Healthcare Update : June 27,2022

Events


Webinars

Sustainable Mobility: Opportunities and Challenges
June 09,2022 - June 09,2022

This event is over. For event material please click here


Seminar

Navigating Disputes in India
February 26,2020 - February 26,2020

This event is over. For event material please click here


Round Table

Investing In Net Zero
July 14,2022 - July 14,2022

News Roundup


News Articles

Impact of Supreme Court’s new covidvaccination ruling on India’s employers
May 13,2022

Quotes

TCS case may throw spotlight on job termination in IT industry
June 23,2022

Newsletters


Pharma & Healthcare Update

Mid-year Regulatory Update 2022: Medical Device Industry in India
June 28,2022

Pharma & Healthcare Update

Mid-year Update: Digital Health in India
June 27,2022

Social Sector Hotline

Roe v. Wade Overruled, NGOs may face reduced international funding
June 27,2022

  • Disclaimer
  • Content
  • Feedback
  • Walkthrough
  • Subscribe
Nishith Desai Associates@2016 All rights reserved.